2006 Young Adults' Choices
Topic: Resources
Yesterday I ran across the 2006 Young Adults' Choices from the International Reading Association. There seems to be the usual angst and extreme topics...the funniest one...based on the titles...being One of Those Hideous Books where the Mother Dies...because there are at least two other books in the list where someone significant does die. In contrast, I saw this article, Bold Books for Teenagers: Trusting Texts That Trust Students in November's English Journal (you must be subscriber to read it here; a print copy should be available soon in almost any college library) featuring some pretty intense-sounding books for teenagers. Male prostitution? Sex with a teacher? I don't know. I've thought this trend toward this type of topic has been an interesting one in young adult fiction, but every time I start reading one of these books, the writing, or story, or something is just too painfully bad. But I keep reading.
Last week, Jessica Crispin wrote an article for the Book Standard about Pop! , a YA novel Borders is declining to carry because of its sexual content. Hey, we all managed to find Forever. Since I have been disappointed by the books of this type I have read, I'm not too upset about it. But I will give the book a try and see. I'm not crazy about the idea of books being kept off the shelves, but I also think that Borders has a right to stock their store the way that they feel will be most beneficial to them. I personally filed a complaint at Barnes & Noble several years ago because they had the young adult section right next to the stage they use for story time. Since then, they have rightly (for both the little kids and the teens) moved the YA section out of the kids' section completely.
At any rate, I'm probably going to be using few, if any of these books in a classroom anytime soon. The only possibility is Day of Tears, mentioned in the EJ article.
Posted by bookweaver
at 4:39 PM EST
Updated: Tuesday, 7 November 2006 2:37 PM EST